1874
Survey Lines and Cedar Bolts1874 Survey Lines and Cedar Bolts: The Making of a Timber Frontier on the Malaspina Coast
In May and June of 1874, Surveyor Mr. Hargreaves conducted a series of timber lease surveys along the eastern shores of Jervis Inlet and the adjacent Malaspina Strait. His observations provide a detailed record of the region’s physical landscape and forest conditions during this early colonial period of resource assessment.
On May 18, 1874, Mr. Hargreaves surveyed a timber lease situated on the shores of Thunder Bay, north of the present‑day location of Saltery Bay. He characterized the area as steep and irregular, noting the presence of good black soil in several locations. The forest cover consisted predominantly of Fir, Cedar, and Hemlock, although he also recorded extensive tracts of burnt timber, indicating prior fire disturbance across portions of the surveyed ground.
Two days later, on May 20, 1874, Mr. Hargreaves surveyed the timber lease at Scotch Fir Point, beginning from the post on the west side of Thunder Bay. His field notes describe the terrain as generally flat inland, but bordered by steep and rocky banks along the shoreline. He identified one small stream within the lease area and again recorded mixed coniferous timber, consistent with the broader forest composition of the inlet.
On June 3 1874, Mr. Hargreaves proceeded southward to survey the timber lease extending from Thunder Bay to the bay now known as Saltery Bay. He observed that the northern portion of this tract was “very rough and rocky,” with comparatively thin timber near Thunder Bay. As he advanced southward, the landscape shifted: the forest became increasingly dense, dominated by Fir, Cedar, and Hemlock, and numerous streams entered the inlet from the interior valleys.
Hargreaves completed the sequence of surveys on June 10, 1874, when he examined the timber lease on the Malaspina Strait side, west of Scotch Fir Point. He described this area as swampy, with black soil and generally level ground, heavily timbered with Cedar, Fir, and Hemlock. Further along the lease, the soil transitioned to rocky, gravelly substrates. During this survey, he encountered a significant stream, which he named Kokanees (now known as Eagle River). He recorded a 30‑foot waterfall in its upper reaches, followed by a canyoned section leading to a lower channel where the water ran swiftly at a depth of three to four feet. The surrounding terrain included extensive swampy areas densely stocked with young Hemlock and Cedar, suggesting zones of more recent forest regeneration.
On August 4, 1874, the surveyor Mr. Hargreaves surveyed a timber lease on the east side of the Malaspina Strait, which began one and a half miles east of Grief Point. Previously, he surveyed the west and north of Grief Point for a timber lease of R.P. Rithet.
The timber lease of August 4, 1874, went south and as far as the timber boundaries, which ended at Coal Creek (Lang Creek). The timber claims traversed the coast of Malaspina Strait, connecting the timber claims of R. P. Rithet and Moody, Nelson and Company from the R.P. Rithet post at Grief Point.
With the two timber licenses of R.P. Rithet and Moody, Nelson and Company connected, the combined timber licenses travelled from Scuttle Bay ( Wilde Road) down the coast to Coal Creek (Lang Creek ).
Independent cedar cutters working in the Malaspina Strait during the early 1870s formed a loosely connected yet highly active network. Researchers can trace their operations through timber‑cutting licenses, customs correspondence, boom tallies, and local oral histories.
May 18, 1874 Thunder Bay Timber Survey (click image to download complete document)
May 20, 1874 Scotch Fir Point Timber Survey (click image to download complete document)
June 3, 1874 Timber Survey Thunder Bay to Saltery Bay (click image to download complete document)
August 4, 1874 Timber Survey East side of Malaspina Strait (click image to download complete document)
Among the earliest was Charles (Charlie) Thulin, one of the first Scandinavian cedar cutters to appear on this stretch of coast. Active between 1873 and 1875, Thulin worked the mainland shoreline directly opposite Texada Island under a series of short‑term licenses. His early presence foreshadowed the later prominence of the Thulin Brothers of Lund, with whom he would eventually be associated as settlement expanded northward along the Malaspina Peninsula.
Working farther south, John (Jack) McGregor logged the Stillwater–Okeover shoreline with a small crew specializing in shingle bolts—a product in high demand in the rapidly growing settlements around Burrard Inlet. McGregor’s licensing history is intermittent, with documented permits issued between 1874 and 1876, suggesting a pattern of seasonal or opportunity‑based cutting. He was also known for an unusual logistical choice: instead of sending his cedar to Burrard Inlet like most cutters in the region, he regularly towed his logs to Nanaimo, likely taking advantage of existing coal‑shipping traffic or personal arrangements with mill operators there.
At the southern end of the Malaspina Peninsula, James (Jim) Atkinson held a full twelve‑month cedar‑cutting license in 1874, indicating a more formal and continuous operation. Atkinson worked the coastline near Black Point, where he maintained a hand‑log boom, an essential piece of infrastructure for independent cutters who lacked the capital for large booms or tug services. His operation represents the typical scale of early cedar extraction in the region: small crews, modest equipment, and a reliance on sheltered inlets for booming and towing.
Not all cutters operated strictly within the licensing system. “Portuguese Joe” Silvey, though not consistently formally licensed, appears repeatedly in customs correspondence, Burrard Inlet boom tallies, and local oral histories. These sources place him cutting cedar on the east side of Texada Island and around Saltery Bay. Silvey often worked under someone else’s license, a common practice among small‑scale cutters who lacked the means or connections to secure their own permits. His presence in both official and unofficial records reflects the fluid, semi‑regulated nature of early coastal resource extraction, where enforcement was inconsistent and subcontracting was widespread.
Rounding out the group is William (Billy) H. McNeill, who operated between Grief Point and Lang Bay. McNeill cut cedar bolts for shipment to Burrard Inlet and held multiple six‑month Timber License Certificates, suggesting a steady, recurring operation rather than sporadic cutting. He was known to camp at the mouth of Sliammon Creek, a strategic location offering fresh water, shelter, and proximity to accessible cedar stands. His activities illustrate the gradual formalization of timber extraction along the Malaspina shoreline as the 1870s progressed.
Together, these men represent the earliest identifiable cohort of independent cedar cutters in the Malaspina Strait, operating at a time when the coast was only lightly regulated, transportation networks were being established, and the cedar trade was beginning to shape the region’s economic geography.
REFERENCES
Field Book Mr Hardgreaves 1873 and 1874





